NECTA Form Six Geography 2
Common Human & Economic Geography Questions & Detailed Solutions
NECTA Geography 2 Assessment Objectives
The National Examinations Council of Tanzania (NECTA) designs Form Six Geography 2 examinations to assess students' comprehensive understanding of human geography, economic geography, and regional geography concepts and their applications. The examination focuses on developing spatial analysis skills, socio-economic understanding, and development perspectives essential for interpreting human-environment interactions and regional development patterns in Tanzania and globally.
Core Assessment Objectives
1. Population Geography Understanding
Analyze population distribution, density, growth patterns, migration, and demographic transition. Students must understand population pyramids, fertility and mortality rates, population policies, and their implications for development in Tanzania and Africa.
2. Economic Systems Analysis
Examine primary, secondary, and tertiary economic activities, their spatial patterns, and development implications. Analyze agriculture, mining, manufacturing, tourism, and service sectors in Tanzania's development context.
3. Settlement & Urban Geography
Understand settlement patterns, urbanization processes, urban systems, and urban challenges. Analyze rural-urban migration, urban growth in Tanzania, and sustainable urban planning strategies.
4. Development Geography
Evaluate development theories, measures of development, development disparities, and sustainable development strategies. Apply development concepts to Tanzania's context and regional inequalities.
5. Transport & Trade Systems
Analyze transport networks, modes of transport, trade patterns, and their role in regional integration. Evaluate Tanzania's transport infrastructure and its position in regional and global trade.
6. Regional Geography Application
Apply geographical knowledge to specific world regions (Africa, Europe, Asia, Americas) and Tanzania's regions. Compare development patterns, environmental issues, and regional cooperation.
Specific Content Areas Assessed
Population Geography
• Population distribution and density • Population growth and structure • Migration patterns and impacts • Population policies • Demographic transition model • Tanzania's population dynamics • HIV/AIDS impacts on population
Agricultural Geography
• Agricultural systems (subsistence, commercial) • Factors affecting agriculture • Green Revolution • Food security • Agricultural policies • Tanzania's agriculture (cash crops, food crops) • Land tenure systems
Industrial Geography
• Industrial location factors • Types of industries • Industrialization strategies • Special Economic Zones • Informal sector • Tanzania's industrialization • Manufacturing challenges
Resource Management
• Renewable vs non-renewable resources • Energy resources • Mineral resources • Water resources • Sustainable resource management • Tanzania's resources (minerals, energy, water) • Environmental conservation
Transport Geography
• Transport modes and networks • Transport development • Transport problems • Regional transport corridors • Tanzania's transport system • Port development • Air transport
Tourism Geography
• Types of tourism • Tourism impacts • Sustainable tourism • Tourism planning • Tanzania's tourism industry • Wildlife tourism • Beach tourism • Cultural tourism
Skills Development Focus
NECTA emphasizes the development of analytical and evaluative skills through questions that require:
• Data interpretation: Analyzing population statistics, economic indicators, development data
• Graph/chart analysis: Interpreting population pyramids, Lorenz curves, line graphs
• Case study application: Using specific examples from Tanzania and other regions
• Policy evaluation: Assessing effectiveness of development policies and strategies
• Spatial pattern analysis: Understanding distribution of economic activities
• Comparative analysis: Comparing regions, countries, development approaches
• Sustainable development assessment: Evaluating environmental and social impacts
Tanzania-Specific Content Knowledge
Students are expected to demonstrate specific knowledge of Tanzania's human and economic geography:
Population & Settlement
• Population distribution (coastal, lakes, highlands) • Urban growth (Dar es Salaam, Mwanza, Arusha) • Rural-urban migration • Population policy • HIV/AIDS impact • Housing challenges
Economic Activities
• Agriculture: cash crops (coffee, cotton, cashew), food crops • Mining: gold, diamonds, tanzanite • Manufacturing: light industries • Tourism: wildlife, beaches, cultural • Informal sector: darajani markets, small enterprises
Regional Development
• Regional disparities (coastal vs inland) • Development corridors (Central, Tanga, Mtwara) • Special Economic Zones (Bagamoyo, Kigoma) • Five Year Development Plans • Tanzania Development Vision 2025 • Regional integration (EAC, SADC)
Examination Structure Focus
Typical Question Distribution:
• Population Geography: 20-25% of marks
• Agricultural Geography: 15-20% of marks
• Industrial Geography: 15-20% of marks
• Transport & Trade: 10-15% of marks
• Tourism Geography: 10-15% of marks
• Regional Geography: 15-20% of marks
Note: The NECTA Geography 2 examination emphasizes application to Tanzania's development context. Students must demonstrate how geographical concepts explain Tanzania's development challenges and opportunities, and evaluate strategies for sustainable development.
Common Examination Questions & Solutions
Population Structure Characteristics:
1. Expansive/Broad-based pyramid: Wide base (43% under 15) indicates high birth rates
2. Youthful population: Median age approximately 18 years
3. High dependency ratio: Many dependents (46%) relative to working age population
4. Rapid growth potential: Even with declining fertility, population will grow due to young age structure
5. Stage in demographic transition: Stage 2/3 (declining death rates, high birth rates)
Development Implications:
• Pressure on education and health services
• Future labor force expansion
• Need for job creation
• Potential demographic dividend if properly harnessed
1. High fertility rates:
• Average 4.8 children per woman
• Early marriage and childbearing
• Cultural preference for large families
• Limited family planning access in rural areas
2. Declining mortality rates:
• Improved healthcare reducing infant mortality
• Better nutrition and disease control
• Life expectancy increasing to 66 years
3. Social and cultural factors:
• High value placed on children for labor and old-age security
• Religious influences on family planning
• Low status of women affecting reproductive choices
4. Economic factors:
• Agriculture-based economy where children are economic assets
• Poverty limiting access to education and family planning
• High child mortality in past leading to compensatory births
Challenges:
1. Education pressure: Need for schools, teachers, facilities for growing youth
2. Employment creation: 800,000+ youth enter job market annually, but limited formal jobs
3. Health services strain: Reproductive health, HIV/AIDS services for youth
4. Urbanization pressure: Youth migration to cities increasing slums
5. Social services demand: Housing, water, sanitation needs
6. Political instability risk: Unemployed youth vulnerable to manipulation
Opportunities (Demographic Dividend):
1. Labor force potential: Large, potentially productive workforce
2. Market expansion: Growing consumer market for goods/services
3. Innovation potential: Youth more adaptable to technology and change
4. Savings and investment: Working-age population can save and invest
5. Economic growth: If properly educated and employed, can drive growth
6. Social development: Educated youth can transform society
Tanzania's National Population Policy (2006 revised):
Policy Objectives:
1. Achieve sustainable population growth
2. Improve quality of life
3. Integrate population factors in development planning
4. Achieve population distribution consistent with resources
Effectiveness Evaluation:
Successes:
• Increased contraceptive prevalence rate (from 20% to 38%)
• Reduced maternal mortality (from 578 to 398 per 100,000)
• Improved awareness of family planning
• Population issues integrated in development plans
Limitations/Challenges:
1. Implementation gaps: Policy-programs disconnect at local levels
2. Resource constraints: Inadequate funding for family planning services
3. Cultural barriers: Resistance to family planning in some communities
4. Regional disparities: Urban areas better served than rural
5. Youth focus limited: Inspecific strategies for youth reproductive health
6. Monitoring weaknesses: Limited data for policy evaluation
Recommendations for Improvement:
• Increase budget allocation for family planning
• Strengthen community-based distribution systems
• Youth-friendly reproductive health services
• Address socio-cultural barriers through education
• Improve policy coordination across sectors
(b) High fertility, declining mortality, cultural factors, economic reasons
(c) Challenges: education, employment pressure; Opportunities: demographic dividend
(d) Policy: some successes (increased contraception), but implementation gaps, cultural barriers
Subsistence Agriculture:
• Purpose: Food for family consumption
• Scale: Small plots (0.5-3 hectares)
• Technology: Traditional tools (hoe, machete), animal traction
• Inputs: Low use of fertilizers, pesticides
• Output: Low yields, mixed cropping
• Examples: Maize-bean intercrop in Kagera, rice cultivation in Morogoro valleys
• Labor: Family labor, gender division (women 70% of labor)
Commercial Agriculture:
• Purpose: Sale for profit
• Scale: Large estates (100+ hectares)
• Technology: Mechanization, irrigation, modern inputs
• Inputs: High use of fertilizers, pesticides, hybrid seeds
• Output: High yields, monoculture
• Examples: Sugar estates (Kilombero), tea estates (Mufindi), coffee estates (Arusha)
• Labor: Hired labor, some migrant workers
Comparison:
• Productivity: Commercial 3-5 times higher per hectare
• Employment: Subsistence employs more people total
• Sustainability: Subsistence more diverse but lower yielding
• Market orientation: Commercial integrated with markets
1. Climatic variability and dependence:
• 95% rain-fed agriculture
• Frequent droughts (central plateau)
• Flooding in some areas (Rufiji, Kilombero)
• Climate change increasing variability
2. Limited use of modern inputs:
• Only 10% use improved seeds
• Fertilizer use: 19kg/ha (vs 200kg/ha in developed countries)
• Pesticide use limited by cost and knowledge
• Mechanization: 2 tractors per 100km² (vs 200 in India)
3. Poor infrastructure and market access:
• Only 10% roads paved, rural roads impassable in rains
• Post-harvest losses: 30-40% for grains, 50% for perishables
• Limited storage and processing facilities
• Exploitative middlemen reducing farmer profits
4. Land tenure issues:
• Customary land tenure insecure for investment
• Land fragmentation reducing efficiency
• Conflicts between farmers and pastoralists
• Large-scale land acquisitions displacing smallholders
5. Limited access to credit:
• Only 5% farmers access formal credit
• High interest rates (20-30%)
• Collateral requirements excluding smallholders
• Women farmers particularly disadvantaged
(i) Irrigation Schemes:
Current status: Only 461,000 ha irrigated (2% of potential)
Benefits:
• Double/triple cropping possible
• Higher yields (2-3 times rain-fed)
• Reduced climate risk
Examples: Mbarali rice scheme, Kapunga rice scheme
Challenges: High investment, maintenance issues, water conflicts
(ii) Agricultural Research & Extension:
Institutions: Tanzania Agricultural Research Institute (TARI), Sokoine University
Achievements:
• Drought-tolerant maize varieties
• Disease-resistant cassava varieties
• Improved rice varieties
Extension system: Farmer Field Schools, demonstration plots
Challenges: Limited extension agents (1:2000 farmers), poor mobility
(iii) Land Tenure Reforms:
1999 Land Acts: Customary rights recognized, Certificates of Customary Rights of Occupancy (CCROs)
Benefits:
• Security for investment
• Collateral for credit
• Reduced conflicts
Implementation challenges:
• Slow issuance of CCROs
• Gender bias (women often excluded)
• Awareness limitations in rural areas
Production Strategies:
1. Increase productivity: Improved seeds, fertilizers, irrigation
2. Crop diversification: Reduce maize dependency, promote nutritious crops
3. Climate-smart agriculture: Conservation agriculture, drought-resistant varieties
4. Post-harvest management: Storage facilities, processing to reduce losses
Distribution Strategies:
1. Market infrastructure: Rural roads, market centers, information systems
2. Food reserves: Strategic Grain Reserve for emergencies
3. Social protection: Food-for-work, school feeding programs
4. Trade policies: Regional trade to balance deficits/surpluses
Integrated Approach Needed:
• National Food Security Strategy (adopted 2010)
• Kilimo Kwanza (Agriculture First) initiative
• Southern Agricultural Growth Corridor of Tanzania (SAGCOT)
• Nutrition integration: Address hidden hunger (micronutrient deficiencies)
Tanzania's Food Security Status:
• Availability: Generally sufficient at national level
• Access: Major problem due to poverty (30% cannot afford adequate food)
• Utilization: Malnutrition issues (34% stunting in children)
• Stability: Seasonal and regional variations
(b) Constraints: climate dependence, limited inputs, poor infrastructure, land tenure, credit access
(c)(i) Irrigation: increases yields but costly; (ii) Research: develops improved varieties; (iii) Land reform: security for investment
(d) Strategies: increase production, improve storage/markets, social protection, regional trade
1. Raw Material Orientation:
• Industries located near raw material sources to reduce transport costs
• Examples:
- Sugar processing at Kilombero (near sugarcane fields)
- Cement at Tanga (near limestone deposits)
- Cashew processing at Mtwara (near cashew production areas)
- Tea processing at Mufindi (near tea estates)
2. Market Orientation:
• Industries located near consumers/markets
• Examples:
- Breweries in Dar es Salaam (largest market)
- Food processing in urban centers
- Printing/publishing in Dar es Salaam
3. Transport Infrastructure:
• Industries located along transport corridors
• Examples:
- Industries along Dar-Morogoro highway
- Mwanza industries near lake port
- Tanga industries near port
4. Labor Supply:
• Labor-intensive industries near population centers
• Examples:
- Textiles in Dar es Salaam (large labor pool)
- Assembly plants in urban areas
5. Government Policy:
• Industries located in designated zones
• Examples:
- Industries in Benjamin Mkapa SEZ (Kigamboni)
- EPZ industries in Dar es Salaam
Structural Challenges:
1. Limited value addition:
• Most industries are assembly/light manufacturing
• Low technology content
• Limited backward linkages to local suppliers
• Manufacturing contributes only 8% to GDP
2. High production costs:
• Electricity: unreliable and expensive ($0.15/kWh vs $0.07 regionally)
• Transport: poor infrastructure increases logistics costs
• Raw materials: often imported due to low local capacity
• Finance: high interest rates (15-20%)
3. Competitiveness issues:
• Competition from imports (especially from Asia)
• Small domestic market (limited economies of scale)
• Quality standards and certification challenges
• Limited export competitiveness
4. Regulatory and business environment:
• Bureaucratic procedures for permits and licenses
• Corruption increasing transaction costs
• Inconsistent policy implementation
• Multiple taxes and charges
5. Skills and technology gaps:
• Shortage of technical skills
• Limited research and development
• Outdated machinery and technology
• Weak innovation ecosystem
Special Economic Zones (SEZs):
Objectives: Attract FDI, promote exports, create jobs, transfer technology
Incentives: Tax holidays, duty-free imports, streamlined procedures
Examples: Benjamin Mkapa SEZ, Bagamoyo SEZ, Kigamboni SEZ
Export Processing Zones (EPZs):
Focus: Specifically for export-oriented industries
Examples: Ubungo EPZ, Mikocheni EPZ
Achievements/Effectiveness:
Positive:
• Attracted some foreign investment (textiles, agro-processing)
• Created employment (estimated 50,000 jobs in EPZs)
• Increased exports (though still modest)
• Provided model for streamlined procedures
Limitations:
1. Limited integration: Most inputs imported, limited local linkages
2. Quality of jobs: Often low-skilled, low-wage employment
3. Limited technology transfer: Basic assembly operations
4. Infrastructure challenges: Zones often lack adequate utilities
5. Implementation delays: Bagamoyo SEZ stalled for years
6. Competition: Other countries offer better incentives
Comparative Success:
• Moderate success compared to expectations
• Less successful than Mauritius, Kenya's EPZs
• Need for improvement: Better infrastructure, stronger local linkages
Role of Informal Sector:
1. Employment: Employs about 75% of non-agricultural workforce
2. Economic contribution: Estimated 50-60% of GDP
3. Poverty alleviation: Survival strategy for urban poor
4. Entrepreneurship: Seedbed for small businesses
5. Goods and services: Provides affordable goods to low-income groups
6. Innovation: Adaptive and flexible responses to market needs
Characteristics:
• Small scale, family-run operations
• Labor-intensive, low technology
• Unregulated, unregistered
• Limited access to formal credit, markets
• Vulnerable working conditions
• Examples: Kariakoo market traders, roadside vendors, Jua Kali artisans
Formalization Strategies:
1. Gradual approach: Not immediate full formalization
2. Simplified registration: Business names registration, lower fees
3. Access to services: Microfinance, business development services
4. Infrastructure provision: Designated vending areas, market stalls
5. Skills development: Training in business management
6. Social protection: Extend health insurance, pension schemes
7. Policy reforms: Review restrictive regulations
8. Organization: Support associations and cooperatives
Challenges to Formalization:
• High compliance costs for small operators
• Complex procedures
• Tax burden concerns
• Lack of awareness of benefits
• Resistance to change
(b) Challenges: limited value addition, high costs, competitiveness, regulatory issues, skills gaps
(c) SEZs/EPZs: attracted some investment/jobs, but limited integration and technology transfer
(d) Informal sector: major employer, poverty alleviation; Formalization: simplified registration, access to services, skills
Natural Attractions:
1. Wildlife resources:
• Serengeti National Park (Great Migration)
• Ngorongoro Conservation Area (crater)
• Selous Game Reserve (largest in Africa)
• 16 national parks, 31 game reserves
• Home to Big Five (lion, leopard, elephant, buffalo, rhino)
2. Landscapes and physical features:
• Mount Kilimanjaro (Africa's highest peak)
• Zanzibar beaches (white sand, coral reefs)
• Rift Valley lakes (Manyara, Natron)
• Usambara and Uluguru mountains
3. Cultural heritage:
• Zanzibar Stone Town (UNESCO World Heritage)
• Kilwa Kisiwani ruins (historical trade center)
• Maasai and other ethnic cultures
• Cultural tourism programs
Infrastructure and Policy:
4. Improved access:
• International airports (Kilimanjaro, Zanzibar, Dar es Salaam)
• Charter flights to national parks
• Visa policies (e-visa system)
5. Political stability:
• Peaceful country compared to some neighbors
• Conservation policies since independence
• Tourism promotion (Tanzania Tourist Board)
6. Private sector investment:
• Luxury lodges and tented camps
• Tour operators and travel agencies
• International hotel chains
Statistics:
• Tourist arrivals: 1.5 million (2019 pre-COVID)
• Tourism revenue: $2.6 billion (2019)
• Employment: 600,000 direct jobs
(i) Geographical Distribution:
• Wildlife tourism: Northern circuit (Arusha, Manyara, Serengeti), Southern circuit (Selous, Ruaha), Western circuit (Katavi, Mahale)
• Beach tourism: Zanzibar archipelago, Mafia Island, Pemba, mainland coast (Dar es Salaam, Tanga)
(ii) Tourist Attractions:
• Wildlife: Safari game drives, wildlife viewing, birdwatching, photographic tourism
• Beach: Sunbathing, swimming, water sports (snorkeling, diving), beach resorts
(iii) Economic Benefits:
• Wildlife: Higher spending per tourist ($150-300/day), longer stays (7-10 days), more employment in remote areas
• Beach: Larger tourist numbers, shorter stays (5-7 days), more mass tourism potential
• Revenue: Wildlife generates 70% of tourism earnings despite fewer tourists
(iv) Environmental Impacts:
• Wildlife: Habitat disturbance, water pollution from lodges, solid waste, carbon footprint of transport
• Beach: Coastal erosion, coral reef damage, sewage pollution, water overuse
• Common issues: Both face carrying capacity challenges, waste management issues
Definition: Tourism owned and managed by local communities, with benefits accruing locally
Examples in Tanzania:
1. Cultural tourism programs: Marangu (Chagga culture), Mto wa Mbu (multi-ethnic)
2. Wildlife management areas (WMAs): Communities manage wildlife on village land
3. Joint ventures: Communities partner with tour operators (e.g., Loliondo area)
4. Community lodges: Owned and operated by communities
Effectiveness Evaluation:
Positive Impacts:
1. Economic benefits: Direct income to communities, employment
2. Conservation incentives: Communities value wildlife as economic asset
3. Cultural preservation: Tourism validates traditional cultures
4. Poverty reduction: Especially in remote areas with few alternatives
5. Empowerment: Communities involved in decision-making
Challenges/Limitations:
1. Limited benefits: Often small scale, modest revenues
2. Capacity constraints: Lack of business and hospitality skills
3. Market access: Difficult to reach international markets
4. Unequal distribution: Benefits often captured by elites
5. External pressures: Competition from large operators, land grabs
6. Policy barriers: Complex regulations, bureaucratic procedures
Success Factors:
• Strong community organization
• External support (NGOs, government)
• Fair benefit-sharing mechanisms
• Market linkages
• Capacity building
Challenges Facing Tourism:
1. Seasonality: Peak seasons (June-October, December-January) vs low seasons
2. Infrastructure limitations: Poor roads to parks, limited airport capacity
3. High costs: Expensive park fees, luxury focus excludes budget tourists
4. Leakages: 40-60% of tourism earnings leak out (imported goods, foreign ownership)
5. Environmental pressures: Overcrowding in popular parks, waste management
6. Climate change: Changing wildlife patterns, coral bleaching, water scarcity
7. Competition: Kenya, South Africa, Botswana offer similar products
8. COVID-19 impact: Severe disruption to international travel
Sustainable Development Strategies:
1. Product diversification:
• Cultural tourism, adventure tourism, conference tourism
• Develop Southern and Western circuits to reduce pressure on Northern circuit
• Promote off-season tourism
2. Infrastructure improvement:
• Upgrade roads to parks
• Expand airport capacity
• Improve utilities in tourist areas
3. Sustainability practices:
• Eco-certification for lodges
• Waste management systems
• Water and energy conservation
• Carrying capacity limits in sensitive areas
4. Local linkages:
• Promote local sourcing of goods and services
• Support community-based tourism
• Skills development for local employment
5. Marketing and branding:
• Target emerging markets (China, India)
• Promote responsible tourism brand
• Digital marketing strategies
6. Policy and planning:
• National Tourism Policy (1999 under review)
• Tourism Master Plan implementation
• Better coordination between ministries
(b) Comparison: Wildlife - northern/southern circuits, safari, higher spending; Beach - coast/islands, water sports, mass tourism
(c) Community tourism: benefits locals, conservation incentive, but limited scale and capacity constraints
(d) Challenges: seasonality, infrastructure, costs, leakages; Strategies: diversification, sustainability, local linkages
Road Transport:
Advantages:
• Flexibility: Door-to-door service, can reach remote areas
• Speed: Faster for short distances, no transshipment
• Infrastructure: Extensive network (91,049 km total roads)
• Employment: Creates many jobs in construction, maintenance, operation
• Small scale: Suitable for small volumes, just-in-time delivery
Disadvantages:
• High cost: Expensive for bulk goods over long distances
• Congestion: Especially in urban areas (Dar es Salaam)
• Maintenance: High maintenance costs, poor condition (only 10% paved)
• Environmental impact: High carbon emissions, accidents
• Limited capacity: Not suitable for very heavy/bulk goods
Railway Transport:
Advantages:
• Bulk transport: Efficient for heavy/bulk goods (minerals, grain)
• Long distance: Economical over long distances
• Lower cost: Cheaper per ton-kilometer than road
• Environmental: Lower carbon emissions per ton
• Safety: Fewer accidents compared to roads
Disadvantages:
• Inflexibility: Fixed routes, requires road connection
• Slow speed: Slower for short distances
• Poor condition: Old infrastructure (meter gauge), slow speeds (30-40 km/h)
• Limited network: Only 3,682 km, not well connected
• Inefficiency: Tanzania Railways Corporation struggles with management
Current Situation:
• Modal split: Road carries 95% of freight and passengers
• Road condition: Only 10,300 km paved, rest gravel/earth
• Rail condition: Meter gauge, needs rehabilitation
For Tanzania:
1. Gateway for trade: Handles 95% of Tanzania's international trade
2. Revenue generation: Port fees, taxes contribute to government revenue
3. Employment: Direct and indirect employment in port operations
4. Industrial development: Port attracts industries (manufacturing, processing)
5. Regional hub: Position as regional transport hub enhances Tanzania's importance
For Landlocked Neighbors:
1. Burundi: Main route for imports/exports (through Kobero border)
2. Rwanda: Alternative to Mombasa port (through Rusumo)
3. DRC (eastern): Serves eastern provinces (through Kasulu/Kabanga)
4. Uganda: Alternative route for some traffic (through Mutukula)
5. Zambia: Serves northern regions (through Nakonde/Tunduma)
6. Malawi: Southern corridor through Songwe border
Port Statistics:
• Capacity: 15 million tons annually
• Traffic: 14.8 million tons (2019), 65% transit cargo
• Berths: 11 deep-water berths
• Container handling: 770,000 TEUs annually
Challenges:
• Congestion and delays (average 10-14 days dwell time)
• Limited capacity for growing traffic
• Competition from Mombasa and Durban ports
• Inefficiency in operations
Development Projects:
• Dar es Salaam Maritime Gateway Project (DMGP)
• Expansion to handle 28 million tons by 2025
• New container terminal at Ruvu South
Project Overview:
• Phase 1: Dar es Salaam-Morogoro (300 km) completed 2019
• Phase 2: Morogoro-Makutupora (422 km) under construction
• Total plan: 2,561 km connecting Tanzania to neighbors
• Gauge: Standard gauge (1.435 m) vs old meter gauge (1.0 m)
• Speed: 120-160 km/h for passengers, 80 km/h for freight
• Cost: $7.6 billion (mainly Chinese financing)
Potential Positive Impacts:
1. Transport efficiency:
• Reduce Dar-Mwanza travel time from 36 hours to 12 hours
• Increase freight capacity (10,000 tons per train vs 800 tons currently)
• Lower transport costs by 40%
2. Economic development:
• Stimulate industries along corridor
• Improve agricultural market access
• Boost tourism through better access
• Create employment (construction and operation)
3. Regional integration:
• Connect to Rwanda, Burundi, DRC
• Compete with Kenya's SGR for regional traffic
• Enhance Tanzania as regional transport hub
4. Environmental benefits:
• Reduce road congestion and accidents
• Lower carbon emissions compared to trucks
Potential Challenges/Risks:
1. Financial sustainability:
• High debt burden ($7.6 billion)
• Uncertain traffic projections
• Competition from road transport
2. Implementation risks:
• Delays in construction
• Cost overruns
• Technical challenges
3. Social and environmental:
• Displacement of communities
• Environmental impacts of construction
• Limited local content in construction
4. Integration with existing system:
• Compatibility with meter gauge system
• Connection to port and other infrastructure
Critical Success Factors:
• Competitive pricing
• Efficient operations
• Integration with other modes
• Maintenance sustainability
Key Challenges:
1. Poor infrastructure quality:
• Only 10% roads paved, many in poor condition
• Railway system outdated and inefficient
• Port congestion and inefficiency
• Limited air transport infrastructure
2. High transport costs:
• Tanzania has among highest transport costs in region
• Dar to Kigali: $4,500 per container vs $3,000 through Mombasa
• Increases prices of goods, reduces competitiveness
3. Maintenance deficits:
• Inadequate funding for road maintenance
• Road Fund Tanzania underfunded
• Reactive rather than preventive maintenance
4. Institutional and regulatory issues:
• Multiple agencies with overlapping mandates
• Corruption at weighbridges and borders
• Inefficient customs procedures
• Limited private sector participation in some areas
5. Safety concerns:
• High road accident rates (16.4 deaths per 100,000 people)
• Poor vehicle maintenance standards
• Reckless driving
Solutions/Strategies:
1. Infrastructure investment:
• Complete SGR project
• Road upgrading and paving program
• Port expansion and modernization
• Public-private partnerships for infrastructure
2. Maintenance prioritization:
• Increase Road Fund allocation
• Preventive maintenance programs
• Community participation in rural road maintenance
3. Institutional reforms:
• Streamline regulatory agencies
• Implement one-stop border posts
• Digital systems for customs and clearance
• Anti-corruption measures
4. Safety improvements:
• Strengthen vehicle inspection systems
• Driver training and testing
• Road safety campaigns
• Improve road signage and markings
5. Multimodal integration:
• Develop dry ports (inland container depots)
• Improve connectivity between modes
• Logistics hubs at key locations
6. Sustainable transport:
• Promote public transport in cities
• Develop Dar es Salaam Bus Rapid Transit (BRT)
• Non-motorized transport infrastructure
(b) Dar port: handles 95% of Tanzania's trade, gateway for landlocked neighbors
(c) SGR: potential for efficiency, economic development, but financial and implementation risks
(d) Challenges: poor infrastructure, high costs, maintenance deficits; Solutions: investment, reforms, multimodal integration
Additional NECTA Geography 2 Questions
Historical Factors:
1. Colonial legacy:
• Development concentrated in areas with colonial economic interests
• Transport infrastructure built to serve export routes
• Education and health services located in administrative centers
2. Geographical factors:
• Coastal regions have better access to ports and international trade
• Highland areas have better climate for agriculture and settlement
• Landlocked regions face higher transport costs
• Resource endowment varies (minerals, water, fertile land)
3. Economic factors:
• Investment concentrates in areas with existing infrastructure
• Cumulative causation (developed regions attract more development)
• Market size differences (larger markets in some regions)
• Employment opportunities vary
4. Policy factors:
• Past development plans favored certain regions
• Decentralization implementation challenges
• Resource allocation formulas may disadvantage some regions
5. Infrastructure disparities:
• Transport network concentrated in some regions
• Energy access varies (80% urban vs 10% rural in some areas)
• Communication infrastructure gaps
Disparity Indicators:
• Poverty: 16% in Dar es Salaam vs 48% in Shinyanga
• Access to electricity: 97% in Dar vs 20% in rural Manyara
• Health facilities: Doctor-patient ratio varies 1:2,000 in Dar vs 1:50,000 in some regions
(i) Dar es Salaam Region:
• Economic: Contributes 40% to national GDP, service sector dominant
• Infrastructure: Best in country (roads, port, airport, utilities)
• Social services: Concentration of hospitals, universities, schools
• Urbanization: 100% urban, rapid growth (5% annually)
• Challenges: Overcrowding, slums, traffic congestion, pollution
• Development level: Highest HDI in Tanzania
(ii) Mtwara Region:
• Economic: Agriculture dominant (cashew nuts), recently gas discoveries
• Infrastructure: Poor roads, limited port development until recently
• Social services: Limited health and education facilities
• Urbanization: Low (25%), mainly rural population
• Challenges: Poverty (45%), food insecurity, limited market access
• Development level: Among lowest HDI in Tanzania
• Potential: Gas resources, port development, agricultural potential
Key Differences:
• GDP contribution: Dar 40% vs Mtwara 2%
• Poverty rate: Dar 16% vs Mtwara 45%
• Infrastructure: Dar has best, Mtwara among poorest
• Economic structure: Dar services-based, Mtwara agriculture-based
Past Strategies:
1. Ujamaa villagization (1970s):
• Aimed to provide services to rural areas
• Mixed results: some service improvement but economic disruption
• Did not significantly reduce regional disparities
2. Growth Center Strategy (1980s):
• Designated growth centers to spread development
• Limited success due to inadequate resources
• Some centers (Arusha, Mwanza) grew, others did not
3. Regional Planning (1990s-present):
• Regional development plans
• Implementation challenges due to limited funds
• Some success in identifying regional potentials
Current Approaches:
1. Development Corridors:
• Central Corridor (Dar-Kigali/Bujumbura)
• Mtwara Development Corridor
• Tanga Corridor
• Effectiveness: Mixed, infrastructure improving but economic benefits slow
2. Special Economic Zones:
• Located in various regions
• Effectiveness: Limited success, most investment still in Dar
3. Sectoral approaches:
• Southern Agricultural Growth Corridor (SAGCOT)
• Tourism circuits development
• Effectiveness: Some progress but slow
Evaluation:
• Limited success in reducing disparities
• Disparities may have increased in some aspects
• Need for more integrated approaches
• Importance of local participation in planning
• Need for adequate funding for regional development
Decentralization by Devolution (D by D):
• Policy since 1998
• Transfer of functions, finances, and personnel to local governments
• Aim: improve service delivery, local participation, accountability
Potential Benefits for Balanced Development:
1. Local decision-making: Decisions made closer to people affected
2. Resource allocation: Better matching of resources to local needs
3. Participation: Communities involved in planning and implementation
4. Accountability: Local leaders more accountable to communities
5. Innovation: Local solutions to local problems
Implementation Challenges:
1. Financial constraints:
• Limited own-source revenue for local governments
• Central government transfers inadequate and unpredictable
• Weaker regions have lower revenue capacity
2. Capacity limitations:
• Limited technical skills at local level
• Weak planning and implementation capacity
• Higher turnover of staff
3. Political and administrative issues:
• Tensions between central and local governments
• Incomplete devolution of functions
• Corruption at local levels
4. Inequalities exacerbated:
• Richer local governments can provide better services
• Equalization mechanisms not fully effective
• Disparities between urban and rural local governments
Success Factors for Effective Decentralization:
• Adequate and predictable funding
• Capacity building for local governments
• Clear division of functions
• Strong accountability mechanisms
• Participation of marginalized groups
• Effective equalization system
Current Status:
• Progress made but still challenges
• Service delivery improved in some areas
• Disparities still significant
• Need for continued reform and support
(b) Dar: developed, services-based; Mtwara: less developed, agriculture-based, high poverty
(c) Strategies: mixed success, some progress but disparities persist
(d) Decentralization: potential for balanced development but faces financial, capacity challenges
No comments
Post a Comment